Why Men Are Worse for the Planet

A typical man. Credit: Fox

A guest post from TIME’s Tara Kelly:

There’s a long history of research that reveals women are the greener gender-at least when it comes to their attitudes and preferences. But now a study published by France’s National Institute of Statistics and Economics shows that the fairer sex’s environmental conscience may actually translate into action too. Put simply, men are worse for the planet than women. While the study found French women emit 32.3 kgs of carbon per day, men compare at a whopping 39.3kg-mainly thanks to a carbon intensive diet and their inefficient use of transport.

But this isn’t the first time researchers have found men behaving badly towards the planet.  Back in August 2009, Annika Carlsson-Kanyama, of Sweden, and Riita Räty, of Finland, found similar conclusions. By examining 10 daily activities of both sexes across Germany, Greece, Norway and Sweden, their findings revealed men consumed more meat and processed beverages than women did, used cars more frequently and drove longer distances, resulting in greater carbon emissions. The differences range from six percent in Norway and eight percent in Germany to 22 percent in Sweden and as massive as 39 percent in Greece.

So what explains the difference in behavior between the two sexes? In an interview with Tierramérica, Corinna Altenburg and Fritz Reusswig, of Germany’s Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research offer their take:

In transportation, for example, men make more trips in airplane and automobile, raising considerably their ecological footprint, according to the two experts. That difference could be balanced out in the future to the extent that equal opportunity allows women to climb the labor ladder, while men take on more household duties.

Yet women also tend to be opt for more vegetarian diets, yielding less carbon: “Meanwhile, eating habits follow the gender line: men tend to eat more meat, and women eat more fruits and vegetables—habits that are difficult to change, according to Altenburg and Reusswig.”

But instead of blaming men, Altenburg and Reusswig suggest the solution may be down to questioning social norms. They say creating policies that target the social expectations of men as equally as the traditional environmental objectives we associate with climate change could be the way forward. But redefining the manly diet is also key—especially given the French study found one man’s intake is responsible for 7.98 kg of CO2 emissions per day, while a female is accountable for 6.79 kg per day.

Related Topics: carbon, carbon footprint, climate change, gender, men, social norms, women, Climate Science
  • Latest on Ecocentric

    Alexander Demianchuk / Reuters

    Global Warming: An Exclusive Look at James Hansen’s Scary New Math

    A new analysis by the NASA climatologist for the first time ties specific weather events to human-induced climate change

    Victor Fraile / Getty Images

    By Sea, Land and Air: Hong Kong Inventor Leads Charge in War Against Pollution

    One Hong Kong engineer puts the city’s surf and turf to work toward a cleaner future

    Paul Souders

    Can Polar Bears Keep Their Heads Above Water in a Warming World?

    Polar bears are classified as marine mammals, like a seal or a walrus, which might come as a surprise given that they’re usually pictured on land. But polar bears spend a lot of their time in the waters of the Arctic, fishing or swimming among the sea ice. They may look awkward in the water, but no creature with paws is a better swimmer.

  • franklovesfl

    Men are larger than women therefore require more carbon to survive. So, you would suggest that we kill all men over 5’6″ to save the planet?

  • http://neerajbhushan.com/ Neeraj Bhushan

    So, is it time men start behaving like women!

  • http://ricardieu.wordpress.com ricardieu

    The author of this article has failed to mention that western women buy more clothes on the average than most western men.

    Since I’m not gay I cannot speak for the queer
    western man in terms of whether their desire to
    be a woman more than a man is reflected in
    their fashion consumption needs.

    Go to any thrift store in America and see how much
    more are the clothes of women present than men.
    It is not only a cliche but it is true that women own
    more pairs of shoes than men in the western world.

    This need to consume via fashion certainly has its
    carbon print to match western man’s need to travel by car etc.

    I’m about to turn 66 years old and travel around my town on my bicycle.

  • http://tisnando.wordpress.com Tisna Nando

    The point is both sexes are almost equal in carbon emission, if we say the average human population on earth responsible for 5 kg CO2 emission per day, than we all responsible for over 34 billion kg CO2 emission per day. Lets reduce it starting from our self.

  • bresner23

    Too bad this chick failed to mention that WOMEN produce most of America’s waste. Here’s the proof: http://goo.gl/f4pXo

  • prabhatmisra

    The most important lesson to be learn from such study is that WE MUST LIVE THE ENVIRONMENT FRIENDLY LIFE. Such way of life must be given the STATUS OF FUNDAMENTAL DUTY in every country. This is a very important study and men should reduce their ecological [carbon] footprint to save the earth from the impacts of Climate Change.
    Prabhat Misra
    http://www.facebook.com/prabhat.lovepeaceunity

blog comments powered by Disqus