A Green Chamber of Commerce Offers a New Voice for Business

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has—how to put this—not been a friend of environmental legislation or regulation. The Chamber—which represents more than 3 million U.S. businesses—spent millions to lead the successful fight against carbon cap-and-trade legislation, along with health care reform and most of President Obama’s other legislative goals. It remains an implacable opponent of EPA environmental regulations—of greenhouse gases or just about anything else, arguing that they raise costs and hurt job creation.

But while the Chamber leadership may be fighting tooth-and-nail against efforts to protect the country’s environment, not every business wants to join the battle. Major companies like Pacific Gas and Electric and Apple left the Chamber in protest of its fight against cap-and-trade, and now a group of progressive businesses in San Diego is working to provide an alternative to the Chamber. It’s called the Green Chamber of Commerce, and it offers a place for businesses that want to embrace sustainability, not fight it. “There are businesses out there that want their voices heard,” says David Steel, the president of the U.S. Green Chamber of commerce. “They don’t feel represented by the positions that the U.S. Chamber might have.”

The group began in San Diego, home to a number of green businesses and sustainability-minded citizens. Like most local chambers of commerce around the U.S. just form committees dedicated to sustainable business—assuming there’s a demand—but the green companies of San Diego wanted something more. So they broke off into their own chamber, a place where entrepreneurs and executives working in renewable power or energy efficiency could trade contacts and advice. San Diego was fertile territory—the city is studded with solar installations, and San Diego’s biotech hub now features startups working on next-generation biofuels. “It was a place where you could network with the like-minded,” says Steel.

But it wasn’t until Proposition 23 that the San Diego green chamber realized that they might be able to go national. Prop 23 was a ballot initiative in California that would have all but suspended the state’s landmark climate change law. Outside business interests—including major oil companies—spent heavily supporting the initiative. But they were beaten at the polls last November—a rare victory in 2010 for environmentalists—thanks in no small part to the organizing efforts and campaign cash of green businesses throughout California. “We spoke about Prop 23 to every city council in San Diego county,” says Steel. “We hope it could represent a real turning point for businesses in California and the rest of the country.”

The success of the anti-Prop 23 effort convinced Steel and his fellow San Diegans that they had something special. Last week the Green Chamber of San Diego announced that it would go national,  forging alliances with E2—Environmental Entrepreneurs, along with businesses in Orange County, Texas and Florida. “We’re looking for companies that are out there being sustainable,” says Steel. “We want to give more visibility to what they’re doing.” If they get loud enough, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce won’t be the only voice representing businesses on Capitol Hill.

Related Topics: Business, California, chamber of commerce, climate change, green business, Prop 23, San Diego, sustainability, Business
  • Latest on Ecocentric

    Alexander Demianchuk / Reuters

    Global Warming: An Exclusive Look at James Hansen’s Scary New Math

    A new analysis by the NASA climatologist for the first time ties specific weather events to human-induced climate change

    Victor Fraile / Getty Images

    By Sea, Land and Air: Hong Kong Inventor Leads Charge in War Against Pollution

    One Hong Kong engineer puts the city’s surf and turf to work toward a cleaner future

    Paul Souders

    Can Polar Bears Keep Their Heads Above Water in a Warming World?

    Polar bears are classified as marine mammals, like a seal or a walrus, which might come as a surprise given that they’re usually pictured on land. But polar bears spend a lot of their time in the waters of the Arctic, fishing or swimming among the sea ice. They may look awkward in the water, but no creature with paws is a better swimmer.

  • http://8020vision.com jaykimball

    When the chamber says they represent 3 million businesses, I don’t think so. They represent a small number of very large businesses. The issues they are pushing are popular with big oil and businesses that harm public health – both US and international.

    No wonder the chamber avoids transparency on where their funds are comig from.

    I applaud the companies that are walking away from the Chamber, due to the chambers backward sustainability policies, and I appreciate those companies saying so publicly – PG&E, Apple, etc.

    Jay Kimball
    8020 Vision

  • http://www.itsgettinghotinhere.org Richard Graves

    Hey Bryan,

    Have you seen Mother Jones’ new round-up on the Chamber of Commerce actual membership numbers?

    Last year, they caught them inflating their membership #s by about 2.7 million. It turns out it might be even smaller than that. It might only have 50-100,000 dues paying members – 94% of its budget comes from 1,500 businesses – particularly 16 large companies.

    “The Incredible Shrinking Chamber of Commerce”
    http://motherjones.com/mojo/2010/11/us-chamber-commerce-size

    Might be a reality-check for them to have to address that.
    -Richard Graves

  • http://taylorshea.wordpress.com taylorshea

    It’s so good to see an organization stepping up to the US Chamber of Commerce. Such similar names, yet two COMPLETELY different groups. This article perfectly distinguishes just how different they are…

    I hope we see a lot more businesses leave the Chamber and join the GREEN Chamber in the next year as they expand…. This seems to be coming at an ideal time–right after the President’s State of the Union, discussing greener investments as a key to our economy’s stability and our community’s sustainability. Perfect timing, really. We need an organization like this right now.

  • http://briansigler.wordpress.com briansigler

    The EPA, NRDC, and other big environmental organizations should join forces with US Green Chamber to strengthen the fight against some of the Chamber of Commerce’s not so eco-friendly lobbying…

  • http://briansigler.wordpress.com briansigler

    Yes, really great job of distinguishing between the two. Key difference: one is GREEN

blog comments powered by Disqus